Fantasy Upside
It's going to be weird seeing Derek Carr in a jersey other than a Raiders one, but he is now the quarterback of the Saints. He joins an offense that includes one of the top rookies from 2022, wide receiver Chris Olave, a hopefully healthy Michael Thomas and an interesting option in Rashid Shaheed. If anything, New Orleans should see better production at the quarterback position than they had between Andy Dalton and Jameis Winston last season.
Fantasy Downside
Taysom Hill is still floating around and the Saints still like using him in the red zone, so if the Saints are close to scoring, there's always the chance Carr won't even be on the field to potentially finish off the drive, limiting his fantasy potential. The Saints will also feed the ball to the trio of Alvin Kamara, Jamaal Williams and, maybe sporadically, Kendre Miller.
2023 Bottom Line
Carr should still be a fine QB2 this season. If Michael Thomas can stay healthy, the offense should open up even more for the Saints and Carr. But the constant threat of Taysom Hill and the running backs cap Carr's ceiling.