Fantasy Upside
Dion Lewis comes over to the Titans after having his most productive NFL season last year in New England, where he rushed for nearly 900 yards and caught 32 passes for another 200+ yards. He also scored nine times, which is not something you see a lot from 5-foot-8, 190-pound runners. He takes over the DeMarco Murray role as the pairing with Derrick Henry, and as we've seen in the past couple of years, Murray has been the more valuable player, particularly in PPR leagues.
Fantasy Downside
Sharing carries is never a good thing, especially when you're the smaller of the two guys. While Lewis is the better receiver, Henry should get the lion's share of carries at the goal line, meaning Lewis getting nine scores again this season isn't likely. He's also got a very lengthy injury history.
2018 Bottom Line
Lewis will be a boom-or-bust fantasy back. Many will remember what he did last season in New England and overdraft him. In fact, his current ADP seeing him being drafted in rounds 6-7. That means he is being taken as a No. 2 or No. 3 running back. I'd consider him as a low-end No. 3 option, but I don't want a guy in a timeshare who isn't going to be the goal-line player and also has a long injury history. That changes a great deal in PPR leagues. After all, Murray had 39 catches compared to 11 for Henry a year ago. But in my eyes, Henry is the better, more stable back than Lewis, who turns 28 in September. That doesn't mean Lewis won't produce. I just think he'll be drafted higher than his actual value.