The knock on Jonathan Stewart has always been based on his injury history, rather than any lack of talent. Last year at this time, he was coming off a two-year stretch where he missed more games than he played, and he was set to split time with DeAngelo Williams, causing him to fall way down in the draft. To reward fantasy owners who rolled the dice on him, he wound up playing in 13 games, finishing with 809 yards on the ground and helping the Panthers win their last four games to sneak into the playoffs. The Panthers are hoping his health and productivity will carry over to this season.
Fantasy Upside
Stewart has a lot going for him this year. The Panthers let the veteran Williams go and Stewart is healthy, at least for now. He’ll undoubtedly be the lead back as long as he can stay on the field, and he’s a versatile player who caught 25 balls last year in a struggling offense. His quarterback is healthier this year as well, and the Panthers made some upgrades on the offensive line, particularly at the tackle positions, that may help him continue the success he enjoyed last year.
Fantasy Downside
The injury history is concerning and is one of the main reasons he’s not a top 10 fantasy option as the lead back in Carolina. Slightly less concerning is the offensive line. While it should be better this season with some new additions, the unit as a whole still has a long ways to go to get to respectability. Quarterback Cam Newton disguises some of the issues up front as a big guy that can hang in the pocket, but this is a group that was one of the worst in the league last season, and Stewart will hope that the new additions and some internal progression will be enough to make room for him. Finally, Newton may disguise some of the issues up front, but he and fullback Mike Tolbert also vulture touchdowns from Stewart, who ended up with only three scores on the ground in 2014.
Bottom Line
With a strong finish last year and nobody ahead of him on the depth chart, we have Stewart as a risky RB2. He’s going to put up some good numbers in some weeks, but his injury history and the fact that he’s only scored 14 touchdowns combined in the past five seasons make him a question mark. Still, with an ADP in the fourth round, he may be worth a gamble as a starting running back who can also catch the ball.