Fantasy Upside
Everyone knows what Shady McCoy is capable of and he is the No. 1 playmaker on the Bills roster. He has rushed for 1,000 yards four of the past five seasons while also catching over 100 passes the past two years. Just two years ago, he scored 14 touchdowns and is a factor all over the field. No doubt Buffalo will rely heavily on McCoy again in 2018, especially with their quarterback situation.
Fantasy Downside
The off-the-field issues could end up hurting McCoy and the Bills. Police are investigating a home invasion incident in McCoy's home. We don't know his involvement yet but it does cast a shadow on his 2018 season. McCoy is also 30 years old and running backs can decline quickly.
2018 Bottom Line
Unless McCoy's legal situation is settled before your draft, stay away. Someone will still draft him in the first couple of rounds and that is too risky. Right now, his ADP is around 25, but there many backs who are more secure picks that will give you similar results.