Fantasy Upside
Nyheim Hines carved a nice role for himself as a rookie last season. As the complementary back, he ran the ball 85 times for 314 yards and two touchdowns. Most importantly, however, he added 425 receiving yards and another two scores on 63 receptions. Hines was third on the team with 81 targets and was on the field for 44% of the snaps available to him. With the Colts’ offense continuing to improve and a year of continuity along the offensive line, Hines could be even more productive this season.
Fantasy Downside
Hines is too small to ever get legitimate workhorse volume, so his upside is limited. The Colts like Marlon Mack as their primary ball-carrier, and seemed to lean more on Jordan Wilkins as the replacement when Mack missed time. While that’s a good sign for Hines’ value staying consistent, it also makes it hard to envision a path to a much bigger role. In standard leagues, Hines is far less valuable since he only found the end zone four times and averages just 6.7 yards per catch.
2019 Bottom Line
Hines is currently going in the 12th round of 12-team leagues, which is decent value in PPR formats with his potential to catch another 63-plus balls. In a standard league, however, that’s probably about right, or possibly even a bit too high. The Colts were second in the league in pass attempts last season, and just 17th in rushing attempts. If you’re not getting the points for Hines’ receptions, his value is significantly less. In PPR leagues, however, he can be a high-floor plug-and-play option for bye weeks and depth.