Fantasy Upside
With the myriad of injuries in the Giants' receiving corps last season, Sterling Shepard led the team with 731 yards and was second to Evan Engram with 59 receptions. While he only scored two touchdowns in a forgettable season for the New York offense, he showed the ability to operate outside the hash marks as well as in the slot, making it likely he maintains a starting role going into his third season. Shepard is shifty and has good hands and scored eight touchdowns two years ago as a rookie.
Fantasy Downside
Shepard was the healthiest of the Giants receivers last season, but he still missed five games. Additionally, the arrival of Pat Shurmur as head coach, combined with the return of Odell Beckham Jr. from injury might make it hard for Shepard to get enough targets to put up consistent fantasy numbers. As T.J. Hernandez points out, “Beyond Beckham, targets will be thin. Shurmur has rarely supported a relevant fantasy receiver beyond his primary target… it’s unlikely that any receiver besides Beckham draws more than 17 percent of targets.”
2018 Bottom Line
Shepard is worth considering due to his starting position on the team and the propensity of Beckham to miss games. Eli Manning in the past has been able to support multiple receivers. However, expecting consistent WR2 numbers from him will be a stretch, and he’s better served as a low-end WR3 or depth option in most leagues. His 12th-round price tag is palatable, but a higher-upside option should be available in most leagues.