Fantasy Upside
Last season, Will Tye emerged as the most consistent tight end on the Giants roster. After taking over for the injured Larry Donnell mid-season, Tye finished the year with 42 catches, 464 yards, and three touchdowns. All of his scores were in the final four weeks of the season, where he amassed 18 catches and 168 yards as well. Tye is young at 24 years old and a solid route-runner, which should allow him to thrive in Ben McAdoo’s West Coast Offense, assuming he can win the starting job over Donnell. Eli Manning has always made use of his tight end, so the potential is there.
Fantasy Downside
Tye has been more consistent, but at 6-foot-2 he lacks the size and athleticism of the 6-foot-6 Donnell. With Donnell coming back from his injury and looking good in camp so far, it’s possible that the two will share time, which could hurt the fantasy value of both players. Additionally, while his numbers were good to close out the season, he wasn’t producing at elite levels which might limit his ceiling.
2016 Bottom Line
Tye is an interesting option who could pan out for fantasy owners this season, but there’s little reason to invest a lot of draft capital in him. He’s available at the very end of most drafts, and we have him ranked outside our top 25 tight ends going into the season, making him more of a TE2 in most league formats. If you’re in a league big enough to warrant a backup TE, then he’s not a bad late-round flyer, but owners are better off grabbing him off the waiver wire later if he becomes the outright starter.